Independent ideas for serious times Issue 01 · July 2026
JTJot-topia
Sign inSubscribe

Community covenant

Disagreement is a practice.

These principles keep our discussions useful when the subject is difficult and the stakes are real.

01

Criticize arguments, not people.

Address the claim, evidence, or inference. Never reduce a person to a label.

02

Provide evidence when making factual claims.

Good discussion requires reciprocity, specificity, and a willingness to be answerable to evidence.

03

Represent opposing views fairly.

Good discussion requires reciprocity, specificity, and a willingness to be answerable to evidence.

04

Avoid insults, harassment, and ideological labeling.

Good discussion requires reciprocity, specificity, and a willingness to be answerable to evidence.

05

Be willing to explain what could change your mind.

Good discussion requires reciprocity, specificity, and a willingness to be answerable to evidence.

06

Do not manipulate discussions through spam or coordinated voting.

Good discussion requires reciprocity, specificity, and a willingness to be answerable to evidence.